Somewhere during the George W presidency, his Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld uttered such an impossible phrase that I have never been able to forget it. It went something like this: ‘There are the things we know, the things we know we don’t know, and the things we don’t know we don’t know.’ It does sound impossible, but each part of the phrase is true. We do know, for instance, that horses eat grass, digest portions of it, and let the rest exit out the other end. We do know that we don’t know the extent of the universe, or if that girl in chemistry class will go out with us. And we know from history that there are many things we don’t know that we don’t know so thoroughly that we cannot even ask a question about them. Quarks, for instance. Would Christopher Columbus ever have launched an expedition to find a smaller part of an atom, about which he knew nothing? Questioned the reason for black holes?
There is no telling what we don’t know we don’t know, by definition, but we do know that such things or actions or principles probably exist because such things, actions, etc, have always existed. We also know this because most of us know something about something that someone else doesn’t even know exists.
Take my friend Dave, for instance. He came for a visit a month before I was to travel to Mexico to visit the shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe. I presumed he knew at least something about her – you can’t go into an authentic Mexican restaurant without seeing her in the classic image, standing on the crescent moon with the rays of the sun behind her – but he didn’t, not a thing, not the name, nothing. Given this, he did now know enough to even ask what she was about – about the miracles she performed and about the presence of an Aztec’s (Juan Diego) cloak that exists today displaying many scientifically unexplainable phenomena (such as microscopic images in her eyes that could not have been depicted by 16th century painters, let alone seen by spectators). Without this knowledge he could not know that a source with powers far beyond human’s comprehension has left us a nearly permanent and undeniable sign of “its” existence. Without this kind of knowledge, he and many others might not believe in such force at all. Such is the power of what we don’t know we don’t know.
This was brought home to me a few days ago through a discussion of the power of evil in this world by a small group of religious Christians (specifically, the members of the Steve Deace podcast). This group often uses Biblical references to discuss current political events, seeing satanic influence in much of what they call the “spirit of the age.” While many do not know the extent of such influence, they do understand that such influence exists. Many, however, have not the slightest clue. They understand that there is good and evil, but almost exclusively in an earthly way. We might say that the Russians or Nazis or ISIS are bad, and as such we are good, but that is generally understood as something clearly political; or that the child molester is evil and so we are good for not being child molesters, but that is seen as something of the law, taken from a cultural background shrouded in the mist of the ages. There are some things that are right and some that are wrong, just because, and a whole lot more that is negotiable.
What the Deace group understands it that there is a battle that is going on in all of our lives between the forces of good and evil at all times and about all things. We do have specific ideas about what is good and bad, as stated, but few see the tension between the two as a reflection of a cosmic conflict that is affecting everything. Thus it is an unknown that we don’t know we don’t know, not because it is hidden from the naked eye like bacteria to 18th century scientists, but because the nature of its reality has simply not been grasped. Paradoxically, it remains an unknown unknown because we think we know it.
This I experienced as fact in an awakening that I didn’t even realize I was having. While I was told about this cosmic struggle in childhood and so realized that supernatural forces were watching me, I then only had a child’s grasp of evil. As a teen, even this tenuous connection disappeared. What was right or wrong became something that was either dictated by my peers – what was cool and what was for jerks – or by a vague understanding of the Big No’s, those actions like murder and major theft – although some of my acquaintances dismissed even these as relics of a usurious hierarchy. Besides these biggies, life’s actions became a struggle not between good and evil, but about competing with the world to satisfy desires.
Somewhere along the line, this changed. Not all of a sudden, but with a gradualness that suddenly became apparent, like the rising moon that takes us by surprise, or a bubble that arises from the depths and makes itself known only after it pops. There, suddenly, I could see what Deace and so many preachers of the fiery word see: that yes, good and evil are fighting in all areas of our lives whether we know it or not, in a classic cosmic battle that JRR Tolkien understood so clearly that he was able to depict it in mythical form in The Lord of the Rings trilogy. This trilogy was not meant to be only a story to entertain but to act as a chilling wake-up call for all who are asleep to the truth that we are, for now and forever, involved in a relentless cosmic conflict.
Who knew? Who even knew enough to ask? Where this awareness came from might be best explained by a quote for the Book of Sirach in the Old Testament: “He created the knowledge of spirit; With wisdom he fills their heart; good and evil he shows them” (chapter 17) As such we can say that the knowledge was always within us, but hidden so well that we did not even think to look for it: that it had become an unknown unknown, just as the master of lies, what we personify as Satan, had intended. For those in prosperous countries today, this blindness is encouraged by living in comfort and ease, much like the Hobbits. Cushioned as they were, they were made unaware of the growing chaos and madness of evil around them. Good and bad to them, as with us, were just words for behaving correctly, as Mom had taught. If not for the heroes of the Shire, Bilbo and Frodo Baggins, no one would have known of this cosmic conflict until it was far too late.
So it is that we can see this world, with insight given to us as if from the magic of the ring, something pulled from another world. So it is that we can see that everything can be put into a basket either of good or of evil, and that the decisions that we make for even small things resound onto bigger things – and vice versa. So, for instance, we will see it in politics. Who is forbidding the word of God to be preached and followed? Who is promoting policies that are against the laws that have been imprinted on our hearts? Who is robbing us of free will, or advancing propaganda that flies against clear and obvious natural law?
We will also see it in our own decisions and behaviors regarding our relationship with others. Do we prey on the opposite sex for some form of selfish gratification? Do we advance ourselves or gain money or influence by selfish and injurious means?
And so on. Some of these considerations might be familiar, even mundane, but it is in the realization that they are all tied together in one great drama, in which each of us is an integral actor, where the revelation lies. In this, nothing is small; the very perception of our natural world depends on our choice of good or evil, the former opening our eyes to the beauty of creation, the latter, to its use only for utilitarian purposes, or as an evil itself. In this world, blessed angels battle fallen angles in struggles throughout each layer or level of creation, with each intimately tied to the other. “As above, so below” extends in every possible direction and into every conceived reality, from the action of drug cartels to the disintegration of galactic systems.
What separates this vision from black helicopter conspiracy theory is that once envisioned, the connective tissue appears already formed, depicted clearly in the holy books for all to see. How one’s eyes are opened depends on one’s tradition, coupled with the inscrutability of grace. It seems that trying helps, with prayer and deeds combined. However it might come, we are surprised as the unknown-unknown becomes a known-unknown, working then throughout our lives towards the known – known. Although the finality can ever be reached in this world - just as we cannot understand everything about the material world - at least we are given a general portrait of a greater reality that is startling in its breadth.
In this, as things become clearer, we find that the story of The Rings is only a reflection on paper of our own flesh-and-blood-and- spirit drama. This drama is big; it is dangerous; it is a monumental challenge that makes each of us a hero or villain, and each life an epic tale of struggle, failure or redemption.