Technically – that is, materially – my life has not changed much since the Corona Crisis. True, I don’t go to the gym anymore, but it is pruning and etc. season here on the farm, making silly weights and such overkill. Since I do not have a punch-clock job, most other movements or habits have not been altered appreciatively. I do watch more TV, however, and read less, as TV is communal, and that gets to the point: although I have no more fear of this disease than I do for the flu, and far less than I do for cancer (which at my age has become a genuine threat), the vast new edicts of government and the changes in many people’s behavior have appreciatively changed my very sense of being. As much as everything seems the same, so it is not. The street view from my window is the same, but there are far fewer cars and trucks. The distant hum of highways has all but disappeared. It seems that, without changing one apparent external item, we have been sent back to the early 19th century.
It is eerie, which casts a vague shadow of fear. Besides the fear of disease, there is also the very real fear of economic collapse, and that, along with prolonged hours of TV, has got me to thinking: what of that great movie screen philosopher, Don Corleone? In “The Godfather,” he was asked something like this: “(God) Father, what is greater, Love or Fear?” To which he replied, more or less, “Fear. Fear brings greater respect.” Or something like that, but Fear was the definite winner. I recall arguing with someone about that back in the ‘70’s after the movie came out, but I can’t remember what was said or even which side I took. It’s been a long time, and besides, I was young and it was the ‘70’s, which was the greatest decade of getting wasted the nation has seen since the Whiskey Rebellion of the 1790’s, but I still remember the movie, and think that maybe this time I can bring a greater perspective to it.
Fear. For years, my son and I have had this game of “What would you rather?” It often goes like this: what would you rather, your eyes plucked out or your legs cut off? Be rich in China or poor in the USA? Be Hitler or a Philippine rag picker? And so on, all of which makes you think in such a way that you can perhaps answer this:
Some really evil Cartel types are looking for your sixteen-year-old daughter, who has fallen in with a bad crowd. She owes $6000 to them for cocaine, and now they are coming for her. She told you her plight only as the car pulled up, so you hid her quickly where only you could find her. They break down the door before you can grab the shotgun, and now they have you pinned to a chair. They pull out your left hand and put a bolt cutter over your pointer finger. The leader tells you that they will start there and continue on to your next hand, and then ‘to someplace even worse’ until you tell them where she is. They say that she will have to work off her debt in a border brothel, not only as payment but as punishment, but will spare you…if you speak now. What do you say? Do you figure they will kill you anyway, let them cut the finger off, then change your mind in fear and terror as reality hits home? Or do you stick to your guns and go out to the bitter end, finger-less and emasculated? Or, even more complicated, would you rationalize that your daughter does not deserve your life or your appendages for hiding her drug habit from you? Would fear, then, determine justice, or would love win out over all?
Could, or should, love win out over fear or even justice? Personally, I do not know what would happen with me, and I never want to find out. I would hope that I would go down with the ship, despite the drug habit, and forgive everything in the name of love and take the horrible consequences. But since I do not know what I would do, this does not answer our question: which of the two is really stronger in the real world, love or fear?
Despotic regimes, or criminal organizations, rely on fear, and fear does seem to work very well. While protesters today often tell us that America is run by Nazis, presenting themselves as courageous warriors for the world, would they be out in the streets if they were to be sent to re-education camps, North Korea style? I would bet 100 to 1 that almost none of them would. For example, a large majority of Venezuelans hate the Maduro socialist dictatorship, but oppression by the army apparently has worked. No longer do we see the marching in the streets. Instead, the prisons have filled, the tanks have come out, and now a once-prosperous country cowers in poverty. And yes, it could happen here. This Don Corleone knows. Fear is very powerful indeed.
Here is where the power of love comes into place. Fear is our default master. It is probable that most of us have a memory of a time in our lives when we did not do the right or noble thing because of fear. But what of those times when we did, out of love for someone or for some ideal? What of the power of that?
That is what the Godfather does not understand. Buckling to fear is the norm, but when that it defied, the power of that negation is many times stronger than the fearful reaction. It is strong in part because it is not the norm, or at least not what we first want to do. To deny our self-protection for the sake of something greater is so astonishing that it is like the atoms in the nuclear bomb, tiny until a certain density of reaction takes place. Then it is greater than any load of standard explosives that could fit on a bomber. The real thing, though, is truly rare, although our myth- makers wish to exploit this anomaly to sell their stories. Tienanmen Square is most often what we get for self-sacrifice, because the density of this kind of love, of this kind of self-denial, simply is not enough to counter the overwhelming explosive impact of fear.
As a site that explores the spiritual, the reader can see where this might go. Here, we might say that this “atomic seed” is the mustard seed or the leavening of the Gospels, manifested by the one sacrifice of Christ for saint and sinner alike that objectively changed the world, probably for all time. This is a miracle seldom if ever seen since, but it does show us the power of love. While faith in the love of God can move mountains, love for an ideal, whether personal or social, can move many more people than fear. It is not a magical formula, but a shadow representation of the eternal spiritual world, a material manifestation that mimics in small what is writ large in the universe. In the human world, one hero might not change the world for all time, but he can inspire many others, and if there are enough, the world can change, if only for a time.
Fear. The defiance of fear is not based on the world, but on something greater than the world. It is ultimately ennobling to the self and to anyone who learns of it. It is where the human world touches the world of the angels, and where the evils of humankind begin to end, for evil exists on a large scale only through fear.
Think of what the world would be if none of us could be controlled by fear. The plans of the depraved and those hungry for power would fizzle out like a damp firecracker. There would be no fuel for them to burn. The world that so many wish for might then come to us without war or purges or pogroms or programs. If we embraced the guidance of the same spirit that enables us to place love above fear, that world would simply be.