We all want to grasp life by the tail and we all have our ways of doing it. Some go deeply into religion, and that can be the best way of all, for it imparts everything with the cosmic significance it really has. But this path can go horribly wrong.
On the road, I listened to a book on CD, Pilgrim's Wilderness by Tom Kizzia, about a man, Papa Pilgrim (I shamefully admit to forgetting his real name, although he seldom used it) who searched desperately for the depth of his identity, which unfortunately was so clouded with narcissism and perhaps mental illness that it caused immense suffering to those around him, including his first wife who supposedly killed herself (at age 16) by placing a shotgun behind her left ear and pulling the trigger (gun owners know how difficult, if not impossible, this would be). The girl was the daughter of John Connolly, the Texas politician who was in the car with JFK when he was assassinated. But Papa's father, too, was rich and influential, a former football star who had spent long years as an FBI agent, and somehow this apparent homicide was quickly passed over as a suicide and the boy, the young Papa, was set free.
But he remained troubled, obsessed with his own power and apparently the need to justify himself. Born in 1939, he was present in San Francisco during the Summer of Love in 1967, taking LSD and bringing the heavens down into himself. He met a 16 year old girl when he was in his early 30's, changed his name to Sunshine or some such, and hit the hippy trail with her before finally falling in with the Jesus Freak movement of the early 1970's, a collection largely of post- acid heads who sought guidance from a reliable, old-time source as their minds spun wildly and frightfully in the infinite cosmos. Most of these settled into a charismatic Christian religion, and most later became middle-age people pushing lawnmowers and helping the children with homework.
But not Pilgrim. Obsessed with himself, he saw in a vision that he MUST be a spiritual reincarnation of Moses, and he moved his wife and young child into the mountains of New Mexico, where they were to have a brood of 14 others. They were thought of as Christian hippies, but they carried guns, and they stole and they poached at the direction of Papa, who thought of himself as the center at the End of the World, an Old Testament prophet with absolute authority over his wife and children and anyone who would allow his dominance. Eventually, trouble mounted and he decided to leave. Alaska was the best choice, he thought, for there he could live as he pleased.
It is a long story and a very, very good one, although chilling. We find that his dominance went well over the line. His children were not schooled, so much so that they were illiterate and were dependent on the word of Papa for God's Word, and he beat them for the slightest annoyance. His self-worship also led him to a long standing incestuous relationship with his first daughter - and eventually he was brought down, known for a while in Alaska @ 2005 as one of the state's most evil men.
And he was. But if we were honest, we could see that his narcissism was only odd for its intensity and duration, for I believe most of us delude ourselves now and then into thinking that we, WE, are the center of the universe. In Papa's case, he believed he was uniquely gifted with the ability to understand God's old book, which always seemed to dovetail with his own needs for dominance, and his desires. For the rest of us, our narcissism is subdued by the need for social approbation, which, in contrast, is a good thing.
But there is a problem with that which has become the problem of post-Industrial society, and that is: who or what informs the social norms? Whether we want to acknowledge it or not, at this point Christianity still provides the narrative for the Western world, although it is now formally out of the hands of Church or God. Our morality is now thought to be common sense, without authority from any god, only the social norms. Thus it is in line for becoming easily rearranged - into, really, anything. For Papa Pilgrim, he used the Old Testament for his firmament, even though for Christians, the old book was superseded by the New Testament (its own internal reformation, that many say the Koran has never had), but even then, biblical scholars could, and often did correct him, much to his fury.
But consider a Papa Pilgrim without any tether but his own extreme narcissism; consider the scenario of such a man dominating a society in moral upheaval, one that had left its sacred roots behind. As with the Kim family in North Korea, there would then be nothing holding him back from recreating everything social in his own image, exactly like Jehovah - and so many despots of the last one hundred years.
We take our heritage lightly now, and look at the Papa Pilgrims of the world as a grim reminder of how bad religion can be. But having no sacred set of ground rules can be so much worse, setting us up for just such a narcissist and his infinite self-indulgence. Multi-culturalism does not consider that the weakened momentum of former sacred rules of behavior can be easily transformed by the most power hungry and, from the old point of view, immoral among us.
As many of us thought in our youth, rules are such a drag. But there will always be amongst us some internal Lord of the Flies, or some animals who think they are more equal than others. Better the rules leavened by time, wisdom and grace than by the biggest pig on the farm. FK