When we arrived in Utah, I was forced to think of Edward Abbey and his classic book, Desert Solitaire. In this, he wrote of his time during the 1950’s as a summer ranger in the parks area, and spoke of the tourist reaction to the arches, the “windows,” the canyons, the massive balanced rocks and the jutting cliffs layered with geological colors: ‘The Midwesterners saw the wonders and spoke of God, but there is no need for God here. These are magnificent works of nature, but there is no god inherent in any of them’ (my paraphrase). And so the dry Canyonlands struck me as well. There was no god there. The size of it all, the great rocks of thousands of tons, the intricate patterns etched into the land, were all well beyond the hands of any god.
Or my god, that is. For any believer in a monotheistic god, this is a ridiculous claim, as God is the maker of all things, including the universe and the very laws of nature, but it was as I felt: my god was not that powerful; how could he be when he was comfortably ensconced in a modest church in a modest town in southern Wisconsin?
That was how I felt then as I walked among the fit young people of the Southwest who were biking up the steep hills, climbing the impossible pinnacles with ropes and pitons, and rafting the roiling waters of the Colorado and Green and San Juan rivers. Amongst them I was nothing but a fat old fart huffing and puffing his way over pedestrian trails trying desperately to keep pace in the high altitudes. Here amidst the grandeur and sparkling energy of youth I was a side-story, a has-been - as was my Midwestern god. Under the cape of a great cliff or in the depths of a shadowed canyon, both had been humbled as if to nothing.
Fortunately, most of those impressions did not last long. For one, how could I expect to compete with the youth that I had once been myself? That was something I had coming to me, and the sting of that truth settled on me like age itself – slowly, and with a bit of humor. On the other hand, I found that I did not have to apologize for God. While I might well be a fraud – of course I am – that is my own defect. We enclose God with our own restrictions and deficiencies, chained as much to our infantile image of Him as we are too many other major concepts. Read Freud. It was, then, not the mountains that made God small, but my own image, one that was dashed apart by the staggering heft of the naked geology of the Southwest.
So it was with you, Edward Abbey, and so, I suspect it is for most who deny anything greater than what they themselves can conceive. We lock the enormity of human potential inside our expectations, just as we lock the unfathomable universe inside a tasteless box of astrophysics and theoretical mathematics – and just as we lock God inside the sermons and tales of our youth, or even in our present-day hum-drum life.
There is more, though, to the Christian god that makes the jump from chapel to mega-universe so difficult to grasp. This is the One who supposedly sent down a fully divine son to live and eat and defecate and die just like the rest of us. This man-god came to preach not the cosmological or geological truths of our universe, but rather moral truths that dealt only with the affairs of humans. Yes, he raised the dead and cured the blind and generally was able to disregard the laws of physics and of life itself, but did he make mountains? True, it was his “father,” as he himself called God, who parted the seas and hovered above the tribes of Israel for forty years as a truly cosmic god, but who even in the time of Christ still truly believed that? More importantly, his son did not crumble mountains and so on, and for those who look at the Christian religion from the outside, there is nothing more to the life of Jesus than a string of moral teachings that are more congruous with the world of the ancient Middle East than with our world culture today.
Should the Son of Man have come to raise mountains from the dust or call down the stars to swoop dangerously close to our little planet? Would that not have convinced us of his divinity and of the total sovereignty of God the Father?
In a word, no. We have about us the creation already, which we have reduced to mental formulae even as we have radically increased its size. The proof of the creator is already here, so obvious that we of little minds often cannot see it. It is the moral truths that we cannot see and that must be brought out, so that we might not only live well among ourselves but lose the blinders of our vanity. It is then that we might see beyond the thin gruel that we have made of our daily lives, and of our perspective of nature. 500 people are said to have seen the risen Christ at the same time, well attested to by many who were put to death for this account, but still we do not believe.
The great canyons and mountains bring us to awe when seen anew, just as the ocean does. This is a start, but do they enlighten us? Or do we become used to them, as backdrops for our ordinary human-centered lives? That is what I had done with the concept of the infinite, which was broken and rebuilt by the renewed discovery of the vastness of nature. But that is not enough, as Edward Abbey’s words exemplify. God is not seen in his mesas and Canyonlands because our vision of Him has remained, for many, as small as our childhood introduction to him. The Midwesterners who spoke of God near Ed Abbey were right and he, in his conceit, was wrong. The grandeur absolutely speaks of God, as do so many things that we have set aside, classified, and taken for granted. Is rising from the dead less spectacular than forming a mountain? Is dying for humanity any less humbling than the expanse of the night sky? Or are they apiece, like youth and old age, combining wisdom and energy and humility to aid in our inner search? What we might find within is not a mass of cliffs and boulders, but rather the given capacity to appreciate all of their grandeur, for that is the only place that this sentiment lies. Awe is not on the outside, but the inside, a gift that can also serve as our source of deliverance. Edward, you made the greatness only as large as your world-bound spirit and are the smaller for it, just as I am the smaller for my comfortable corn-belt god that is humbled by the size of a cliff.