There are tears and then there are tears; there are times to cry for some while not for others; and few are shed by the average American for anything but something at least as deep as the chest, and usually as deep as the chasms of the heart and soul.
For this I must just talk about us in the US, for crying is controlled by culture almost as much as sex is. The tough-as-nails Comanche, for instance, could torture a pregnant woman to death, or have an enemy shove burning embers down his throat, without shedding a tear. But if one of their own was killed, especially more than one, the tears HAD to flow with histrionics, to be followed by vows of vengeance, which would continue the cycle of sorrow and hate for at least another generation. We also have the tough old warrior Jews wailing at the loss of children or wives or kingdoms, as did or does just about every male warrior in any war culture. As said, righteous sorrow cooks up some pretty righteous anger, and anger makes a pretty fearless warrior.
But for us, tears are a more private and often shameful thing. We all know that men are not supposed to cry for just about anything, and for that, I am glad. We have enough loss of control in our culture. Unfortunately, that does overflow into things men can cry over, like the death of a parent or child, or the marriage of a daughter or birth of a child or grandchild. Women can cry over lesser things, but not to the point of seeming to be unstable. We know what those things are intuitively. A woman can cry over her son getting a scholarship to Big U, but not over spilt milk, at least in ordinary times. Children can cry over everything, but are quickly taught the limits after reaching a degree of linguistic fluidity. Just as potty time must be controlled, so must tears, as with appetite, as with adult drinking and sexual satiation. Much of culture is control, after all, and culture is the essential reason why humans have remained viable as a species.
Culture also recognizes its limits, however, or at least a good one does. A certain degree of creativity is allowed in most, as is the breaking of certain rules in certain situations (or following different rules in different situations). Tears – crying – are allowed with us, as we have seen, in specific emotional situations depending on one’s gender, age, and position in society. For us, tears must and usually do come from a deep emotional well. That is why they must be regulated, and that is why they must also sometimes be allowed. Deep emotions are like blood to the limbs of culture – they keep it alive and healthy. We just have to keep a check on the daily blood pressure numbers for all-around health.
So that’s it – we are brought to tears by extra-ordinary emotional events, good or bad, and are allowed or even encouraged to express them in certain circumstances. But there are some events that stray from our cultural path into a liminal, or twilight zone. We might, for instance, cry with certain music. Sometimes it is because the song reminds us of a particularly poignant episode, but sometimes not; sometimes, we cry from it because it elicits an uncontrollable welling of unknown emotions that cannot be shut down. For me and my wife, this happens when we listen (from a good speaker) to Thomas Tallis’s Spem in Alium, just about every time. It is as if the music draws out something from within and jets it through us in an irresistible surge. We like the feeling, but do not like to be seen while weeping, so we listen to it – only now and then, as if it were a strong drug – by ourselves. These tears are not shameful for the self, but are too much for public viewing. As said, a twilight zone for tears.
Thing is, Tallis’s music is fundamentally and at its core a chorus for a high Catholic Church service.
And so we are brought to those other tears in the twilight, the tears of religious faith. I have a cousin who was once a pretty bad-ass dude. Once, when he was about 20, a guy failed to pay him for an amount of cocaine. So J….. punched him out and then dragged him to a tree (they were meeting in a forested area) and tied him up. For the night. J…. was later brought before a court for drug sales, assault, and by far the worst, kidnapping. After thousands of dollars in lawyer fees and the pleading of his war-vet father, he was released with all sorts of community service provisions and demands. During that time, J…. “got Jesus,” and that was it forever, right up to this day some fifty years later. In any conversation he cannot help but bring up his conversion and/or his faith, and with that come the tears, this from someone who is still a pretty tough guy. We get a little embarrassed for him, and the non-religious move to the other side of the picnic area or room, but he doesn’t care. He inhabits his twilight zone with absolute self-assurance.
I have been to more Christian retreats now than I care to recall because I have become the background guitar player, and I see tears every time in a host of people, from fragile old ladies to big bruisers. Another relative who was raised Catholic but only pops into a service once every few years told me that he starts crying like a baby every time the bread and wine are consecrated. That might be why he seldom goes, not for the feeling but for the exposure of the feeling. I have my own experiences with faith and crying, all leading to the question: why? Crying for faith is not prohibited, but it is not condoned either. It is not a sign of weakness, but it is a little too personal for the individual weeper and for those around him. So why, since it is an embarrassment, would people be unable to stop crying at spiritual moments?
Death of a loved one, the wedding of a child, both are OK to cry at, and both are signals of the deepest kinds of transformation. Intensely beautiful music can bring out tears that are yanked from an emotion too deep for daily use. For its part, Spirit brings forth both intimately- related sensations, giving us a clue as to the nature and reality of Spirit. Since it is almost certain that nothing that is not related to the ‘real’ can bring out intensely tearful responses, we must give a nod to the actuality of Spirit. And since nothing trivial can bring out such responses from ordinary people, we know for certain that the presence of Spirit is anything but trivial.
Spirit, then, is most likely real, or points to something real, and is most definitely something that is experienced with intensity. We understand the tears at a funeral; those at a wedding are a little more baffling. We understand, for instance, that the life of your once- baby girl is taking on a great change, but why the tears? Even more puzzling are those shed for music, or some other art; and even more are those for Spirit. Why, for Spirit, should we experience such emotions for something that cannot even be seen or heard? For something that was never your now- deceased father, or for something that never once played on your knee?
It must be because Spirit comes straight from our heart and soul. This is where its reality lies. It is life-transforming in its realization, as it is outstandingly for my cousin, just as it is intimately, deeply emotional. It goes to our very core. It is both in us and part of us. The startling thing, and a good part of what makes us cry, is the simple discovery of its presence. Like good sex with the same spouse, it can be a surprise and a delight every time, and, unlike the spouse or music, it is forever with us. More mysteriously, it does not give us a directly physical delight. Rather, it arises not primarily from our physical depths but from beyond any organ, beyond our eyes and ears and our tactile senses. It arises, rather, as a realization of our being.
So both Spirit and our ‘being’ exist, and both exist outside of physical reality. More, Spirit affects our being with joy and an ecstasy that often brings us to tears, however embarrassing they might be. Not the “tears of a clown/when there’s no one around,” but the tears of an immortal being encountering its truth as an immortal being whether anyone’s around or not.
Deeper than an ocean, vaster than the sky, more terrible than an exploding star, such is within all of us just waiting to get out. The well of tears is only a distant warning or harbinger.
It is why the wise fear the Lord, and why the bravest among us might weep.