I was sitting near an elderly woman as she bled out her confession: she had lived with a man without a proper wedding for several years before his death. She had married her first husband while still in her teens and he had been a “mistake.” Now that both had died, she could live in full communion with the Catholic Church, but it was obvious that she still held a considerable amount of shame about her earlier relationships. So obvious, in fact, that I felt compelled to help deliver her from her self-condemnation.
That was easy to do. As a child who came of age in the 70’s, I am no stranger to all sorts of intimate relationships, and really, the only thing I feel bad about now is how I may have treated some women as temporary commodities. The official status of the relationships and levels of intimacy I had with them does not haunt me, and as such, her feelings of remorse seem overblown and easy to dismiss. Even more, I had just heard the book, “7 Lessons from Heaven,” on CD and learned from this that everyone who wants to, goes to heaven. Nice and easy, huh?
The big religions tell us otherwise, reminding us that we are all too imperfect to stand before God or to be set free into Nirvana. The logic is strong – I know that I do not have the moral purity to stand before the one and only Truth of everything – but then again, God is Love, so much so that his love for us is deeper than anything we can imagine. So would not the one and only maker of the rules bend them so that we might live in ecstasy beside him despite our flaws? Wouldn’t we do that for our own wayward but beloved children?
That is what we learn from the author of said book, Dr. Mary C. Neal, a specialist in spinal surgery and no fool. Her story is exceptionally compelling and can be seen in the mini-series Surviving Death on Netflix. There, she tells us that she and her husband had taken a great adventure with some friends to kayak a river that ran from the Andean Mts. in Chile. The river was fast and brimming with white water, but they had studied the route that ran through the near-virgin terrain and felt confident that they knew how to survive the major rapids and falls. So it was that Dr. Mary was not surprised or worried when she heard the rush of a large falls ahead. She knew that she had to take the right-hand route to avoid the much rougher falls to the left, but when she got there, she found that one of her companion’s kayak had gotten stuck and blocked the route. Deciding what to do in a fraction of a second, she headed for the larger falls and prepared for the crash. She had, after all, done this several times before and had come out ruffled and a little bruised, her ego suffering more than her body. This time, however, the tip of her kayak got stuck in a boulder beneath the falls, and her body was held ten feet below the surface by the pounding falls. She felt her legs being broken as the force of the water pushed her towards the front of the kayak, and then she was gone.
Her body was still stuck below water (for 30 minutes, it turned out), but her consciousness had risen from her body to somewhere else. She saw the light and felt the ecstasy, went through the Life Review, and then found herself in Heaven. You can read the book or watch the series for more detail, but the upshot is that she believed from the ecstatic love that she received, as well as from an embrace by Jesus, that she had indeed made it to Heaven. During the Life Review, she experienced all sides to all of her actions on Earth, an experience she said was about learning, not chastisement. During this time, her inner voice told her that all who wanted to go to Heaven would. From that she ascertained that some might choose NOT to go, but she could not understand why. It was, after all, a completion and fulfillment of all her, and by extension our, needs forever.
She follows up with wonderful advice, her “7 Lessons,” and goes through a detailed explanation of why Near Death Experiences cannot be phantoms of a physical brain. What lingered with me, however, was the ‘everyone can go to Heaven’ bit. After reading and hearing all my life from all major religions and most tribal ones that getting into Heaven is really, really hard to do, this insight inspired optimism and hope as well as unwanted doubt. Ahead are my thoughts about both, and a sort-of conclusion:
- We all get into Heaven if we choose
Yes, it sounds too good to be true, even though Christians (at least) are told that God is pure love. However, there is some scriptural and psychological backing for this. For the latter, I bring forth Julian Jaynes’ ground-breaking book The Origins of Consciousness (1976). Here, he lays the groundwork through ancient texts for the proposition that a fundamental change in consciousness occurred sometime around the beginning of the “Current Era (CE), or what was more correctly called “A.D.” Through this research he believes that at one time, our ancestors (and current era primitives) actually saw and talked to gods because the left and right hemispheres of the brain had not been fully separated. In this we find that they had a greater intuitive knowledge, i.e., a “one-ness with nature,” due to their inability to separate the dreaming mind (the right hemisphere of the brain) from the mind of the concrete (the left hemisphere). With this, humans also saw ghosts and talked to gods who, to us, would only appear as vague images perceived by the sleeping mind. The upshot being, for our purposes here, that the West went through a fundamental change in consciousness between the Homeric Age (700 BC) and the propagation of Christian teachings. This consciousness followed the West as its influence travelled throughout the world. We, then, are not the same people as we were just a few thousand years ago.
For some, such as the Indians I lived with 40 years ago in Venezuela, the time for this change still had not come. For those in Europe, the change came primarily with the Roman conquest and the introduction of Christianity. With the former came logic, but with the later came the development of a super-conscience which, I believe, further removed us from our impulsive behaviors. This made us less intuitive, but I believe this also opened the door to the Holy Spirit. According to my reading of Scripture, the Holy Spirit enabled us to become consciously moral (among other things) through seeing others as ourselves. According to Christians, this spirit did not come until Pentecost, 50 days after the resurrection of Jesus, and it was clearly meant to change everything. How might we best describe this “everything” in broad terms?
Could it be this: that with the resurrection of Christ and the dispensation of the Holy Spirit, we have all become eligible for Heaven? Could this ability to genuinely have compassion for others ‘as ourselves’ make us all capable of receiving post-mortem divine teaching? And could “purgatory” be the Life Review, the “appearance as if in a mirror” that Paul and James spoke of in the Gospels? Could Hell only be for those who knowingly reject the Holy Spirit, this holy love that is offered them? Could then our Dr. Mary be right? Might all of us who are open to this Holy Spirit, either in life or immediately after death, also be welcome in eternal paradise?
- The passage to Heaven is a Narrow Gate
Most of us were brought up with this second vision, because Christ himself told us this very thing. We are imperfect, so much so that we must be refined in the furnace of the Lord before we can pass unto Him. For some, the imperfections are such that they will simply burn forever. In the parable of Lazarus and the rich man, the rich man seems to be stuck in a sweltering hell, not because of something he did, but because he wasn’t generous enough for those in need. The list of those condemned to Hell in the New Testament can go on, but I think this is enough. We have been told that we may be cast into eternal torment for not dropping a dollop of bread or a coin into a beggar’s hat. That is one heck of a narrow gate.
Conclusion, kind of:
Technically, the Holy Spirit did not come upon Man until after the death of Christ, and so the dire warnings of Christ would have been to a more ‘primitive’ people. Maybe. Considering all things together, our options are: one, we are damned to Hell unless we are nearly perfect OR have complete faith in Christ, as did the thief on the cross next to Jesus; two, there is no heaven or hell, as these are just remnants of the primitive conscious; and three, that the life and death of Christ did unleash the Holy Spirit on Mankind – even to those of other faiths - which fundamentally altered us. With this, we are now able to understand the education we receive through the Life Review given us at death, so that we may then pass into some realm of Heaven.
I can’t really tell anyone for sure which of the three options is true. However, research done by Jaynes, as well as the mounting evidence for the reality of the NDE, strongly hint that the best is option #three. That makes of our life journey more of a hard learning lesson than a punishment for Original Sin, which softens the contradiction that our loving God is a vengeful god. That still does not take away from our having to live with the consequences of our actions here on Earth. In that, the moral admonitions given to us in the holy books are well worth paying attention to. But it might well be that if we can put aside our foolish pride after death and allow ourselves to be taught “as children,” we might find that God is truly pure love, a force who will fully embrace all of us who wish this. Who among us would reject this great love for the pettiness of the selfish little ego?